Welcome to Benjamonster's TV - a place that covers broadcast networks with reviews, ratings, and other features!

Sunday, March 1, 2015


Here is my Freshman Scorecard for March. As always, these are ranked from best to worst chance of survival. Premiering over the next month are Secrets & Lies, American Crime, and Moment of Truth on ABC, Battle Creek and CSI: Cyber on CBS, One Big Happy on NBC, and The Last Man on Earth on FOX.

Past March scorecards: 2014   2013   2012   2011


How to Get Away with Murder - A sure thing for renewal. TGIT has been a dominant force this season. 99%

Black-ish - After a strong start, it took a hit against Empire but has leveled off lately. It'll surely come back, but will ABC put it on a different night? 98%

Fresh Off the Boat - It's looking really good for ABC's new Tuesday comedy. It's been the biggest self-starter in a difficult slot in awhile and has some positive buzz. Even if it slips some in the weeks to come, I think it's done enough to get a renewal. 80%

Cristela - The success of Fresh Off the Boat probably doesn't help this show's cause unless ABC wants to open up more comedy hours on its schedule. I don't think it's looking as positive as it did a month ago. 25%

Forever - As I've said all season, the full season was a victory. A second season is very unlikely. 10%

Marvel's Agent Carter - I don't think it did enough to get a second season with a pretty low-rated run. I guess if ABC really wants to bridge the Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. gap again, it might have a small chance. 15%

Galavant - Very unlikely as it already seems pretty forgotten. 10%

Selfie/Manhattan Love Story - Cancelled.


NCIS: New Orleans/Madam Secretary/Scorpion - Renewed.

The Odd Couple - It's had a positive start. It'll probably not go low enough with a Big Bang repeat and CBS is need of comedies so I think it's looking good. 80%

Stalker - A very unlikely returner. It left an episode unaired and CBS has plenty of freshman drama hits. 10%

The McCarthys - Getting pulled early from the schedule after not getting a full season is as close as it gets to an official cancellation. 1%


The Mysteries of Laura - A rise this past week and the disastrous performances of NBC's other new dramas is surely helping this show's case. It's the only newbie on NBC that hasn't gone below a 1.0 demo. I'm more confident in this show's chances than I was a month ago. 60%

Constantine - Very unlikely to return but it has a better chance than the horrible options that follow it on this list for NBC. 10%

State of Affairs/Marry Me - Completely unlikely after very troubling winter runs. 2%

The Slap/Allegiance - Even more unlikely as they are single-handedly destroying NBC's new Thursday lineup and could dip even further. 1%

Bad Judge/A to Z - Cancelled.


Empire/Gotham - Renewed.

World's Funniest Fails - Very possible to return as a filler or Friday option. 60%

Backstrom - No chance to return but it's survived enough to probably finish its run this spring. 10%

Mulaney/Red Band Society/Utopia/Gracepoint - Cancelled.

No comments:

Post a Comment