Skip to main content

PILOT REVIEW: Smash

SMASH










Starring: Debra Messing, Jack Davenport, Katharine McPhee, Christian Borle, Megan Hilty, Raza Jaffrey, Jaime Cepero, and Anjelica Huston

Created by Theresa Rebeck
Written by Theresa Rebeck, Directed by Michael Mayer

Smash is the highly anticipated new drama from NBC that takes a look at the inner workings of putting on a Broadway musical about Marilyn Monroe. The talented ensemble includes writers Julia and Tom (Debra Messing and Christian Borle), producer Eileen Rand (Anjelica Huston), and director Derek Willis (Jack Davenport). Then there are the two starlets vying for the lead - the experienced but non-star Ivy (Megan Hilty) and the undiscovered Karen (Katharine McPhee). Rounding out the main cast is Karen's boyfriend Dev (Raza Jaffrey), who works in the mayor's office and Tom's assistant Ellis (Jaime Cepero). The dynamics within each character's life and with each other were introduced in the pilot.

THE GOOD: This is everything a good pilot should be. It creates intrigue and drama, it nicely defines and creates characters, and it seems like a show that has so many good things in front of it. There is nothing quite like this show on TV right now (and no, it is not anything like Glee). There is a very New York feel to it and it feels very authentic and true to what things might be like, even if it is somewhat glamorized. The cast is good from top to bottom but Katharine McPhee and Jack Davenport are early standouts. All in all, it was an extremely well-produced pilot that lived up to expectations I had.

THE BAD: This will be nitpicking but since I have the section, I do question how fast the pilot moved - I felt like it skipped over some parts that could have been explored deeper and now it's too late. Also while McPhee's performance of "Beautiful" was very good, was it really so amazing that it made all the higher-ups stop and watch? Finally, this is no fault of Smash but NBC's urgent desire to make this work led them to give away too much in the ads in my opinion.

BOTTOM LINE: Shows like Smash deserve to be successful. It is so well produced and thought out. The quality of acting, writing, and production are all top notch and its really presenting something that hasn't been presented before. I don't know if it will be a hit, I question if it's too "inside" to theater people to be a mainstream success. But I sure hope it is, well, a smash.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

EPISODE GUIDES: That 70s Show Season Seven

On Thursdays, I go through classic series with a critical look at each season. Today I am looking at Season Seven of  That 70s Show ! THAT 70s SHOW: SEASON SEVEN 2004-2005 25 episodes The seventh season of  That 70s Show  is the final season with Topher Grace as a series regular and also the final full season for Ashton Kutcher. Despite still having both of those cast member, the show finds itself flailing especially with Topher Grace's Eric, who is stuck in a terrible arc for most of the season. The show also brings many characters back at one point or another but everything just feels tired. This season actually graded out the worst for me. Even worse than the often maligned final season (more on that next week). Every title this season is named for a Rolling Stones song. Starring Topher Grace as Eric Forman  (25 episodes) Mila Kunis as Jackie Burkhart  (25 episodes) Ashton Kutcher as Michael Kelso  (25 episodes) Danny Masterson as Steven Hyde  (25 e...

EPISODE GUIDES: Rhoda Season Five

On Thursdays, I go through classic series with a critical look at each season. Today I am looking at Season Five (the final season) of  Rhoda ! RHODA: SEASON FIVE 1978 13 episodes Rhoda' s final season was a truncated one as the show was cancelled in December 1978 after only 13 episodes had been produced (and only nine had aired). This feels like a continuation from season four in many ways except with the ill-advised split between Ida and Martin (more on that below). While  Rhoda  has an occasional good moment and even a couple decent episodes, it is a show that seems so wildly different from season one and not in a good way.  Rhoda  could never figure out what it fully wanted to be and only made it four and a half seasons as a result. Starring Valerie Harper as Rhoda Morgenstern  (13 episodes) Julie Kavner as Brenda Morgenstern  (13 episodes) Ray Buktenica as Benny Goodwin  (11 episodes) Kenneth McMillan as Jack Doyle  (9 episodes) Nancy Wa...

SCHEDULES OF THE PAST: 1995-1996 Thursdays

On Tuesdays, I take a look at schedules from yesteryear. Here's a look at Thursdays in the 1995-96 season! ABC 8:00 8:30 9:00 10:00 Sep Charlie Grace The Monroes Various Programs Oct Murder One Nov Various Programs Dec Various Programs Thursday Night Movie Jan Feb World’s Funniest Videos Before They Were Stars! Mar Apr May NBC was the powerhouse on Thursday nights but ABC still gave it the old college try in the Fall of 1995 with a trio of new dramas that they hoped would help them cut into the Peacock's dominance. Headlining their night was Murder One , a high profile new show from Steven Bochco that received much of the network's attention before the season started. The series focused on one murder case for an entire season, whi...